How Do I Discuss This with My Daughter?

David Epstein, MD, discusses the recent supreme court decision, explaining that it does not support a woman's right to autonomy, with regard to abortion.

Healthcare providers are bound by medical ethics to guide the care that they deliver.

The underlying ethical principles in medicine are (1) beneficence or “to do good”, (2) non-maleficence or “do no harm”, (3) autonomy or respect for the self-determination of the patient, and (4) justice or equitable distribution of care to patients.

Each healthcare encounter that we are involved with is governed by these principles in some way or another.

When the supreme court of the United States eliminated the constitutional right to a medical procedure for women by overturning Roe vs Wade, on June 24th, 2022, I was speechless.

The right to an abortion and a women’s right to choose are bound and supported within the framework of basic medical ethics. While all the ethical principles have equal importance, the principle that resonates in this particular ruling is autonomy.
Autonomy has always been a part of medical care in the US, but the culture of medicine was previously more paternalistic in nature like that of a parent/child relationship.
Paternalism propagates the idea that medical care is dictated by the medical team without full consideration for the autonomy of the individual who requires the medical care.
Paternalism doesn’t fully disregard the autonomy of a patient’s right to self-determination, but it basically says that “we know more than you and you need to listen to us.” The physician tells the patient what to do and the patient obeys.

In the current era of medicine, the care model has shifted more away from the paternalistic culture and more toward patient autonomy and patient-centered care models.

With a more patient-centered and autonomy-focused model, the physician and the patient make a shared decision about a medical plan and the patient’s opinions and desires are weighted more in the final decision. We respect the decisions of mentally competent patients or surrogate caregivers to make the right medical decisions for the interested party.
Autonomy is not only a governing principle in medical ethics but also a governing principle of the foundation of personhood in life.
At this point, it is important to quote Justice Ruth Bader Ginsberg. She said, “The decision whether or not to bear a child is central to a woman’s life, to her well-being and dignity. It is a decision she must make for herself. When the government controls that decision for her, she is being treated as less than a full adult human responsible for her own choices.”
To not allow competent individual to make their own decisions in their medical care or life is to take away a piece of their humanity.
This is a good example of why, in medicine, autonomy is a coveted principle in medical ethics and, additionally, in life.

With the supreme court decision this week, it saddens me to know that half of the population of the US has had their autonomy diminished.

I have a daughter. She is faced with the knowledge that her rights have been affected because of her gender.
While one could argue that the ruling was not intended to discriminate against women, one would overlook the fact that only women can become pregnant at this time (for those who are able to get pregnant).
So, how could one not conclude that this decision that affects the right to self-determination is not gender-based bias?

Because one cannot ignore the gender-based bias, the supreme court decision leaves me with more questions.

As a person in our society, how can I justify the supreme court’s decision in this day and age?
As a physician, how can I explain that half of the population has just lost autonomy over their own medical decision-making?
As a father, how do I discuss all of this with my daughter?

Tweet this out


This learning experience is powered by CMEfy - a platform that brings relevant CMEs to busy clinicians, at the right place and right time. Using short learning nudges, clinicians can reflect and unlock AMA PRA Category 1 Credit.

Ad from SoMeDocs.

SoMeDocs Front Page Header

Don’t Settle for Boring Health Resources

Our Venture Amplifies Healthcare Resources.

Ad from SoMeDocs.

SoMeDocs Front Page Header

Marketing physician voices uniquely!

Our Venture Amplifies Healthcare Voices.


SoMeDocs, short for Doctors on Social Media, is a physician-created & led health media company that aims to build a beautiful catalogue of verified online healthcare voices. Our goals are to teach educated professionals tools for personal success, and to showcase them to the world, and facilitate the connections needed to grow. Join us.

The True Art of Medicine

The True Art of Medicine

Susan J. Baumgaertel, MD shares special and unexpected personal story about the art of medicine, our human connections, and the art all around us in nature.

The Late Night Texts

The Late Night Texts

Holly MacKenna, MD shares a story of how an unwelcomed text reminds a female of physician of past traumas and leads to an unexpected opportunity for post traumatic growth.

The Late Night Texts

The Late Night Texts

Holly MacKenna, MD shares a story of how an unwelcomed text reminds a female of physician of past traumas and leads to an unexpected opportunity for post traumatic growth.

Negotiation series header: David Norris

Negotiate as a Physician and Win

Catch this 8-part series, hosted by physician & business consultant David Norris, MD, MBA & produced by Dana Corriel, MD. Learn to be a stronger negotiator with these important tactics.

Conversations with Shem: Season 2

Medical literature icon Samuel Shem, author of “The House of God” returns for season 2 of conversation, in order to discuss the broken healthcare system. This time, he’s brought the guests!

Doctors on Social Media Teach Podcasting Header Image

Doctors On Social Media Teach Podcasting

Today’s health experts are sharing their expertise in audio format using podcasts. Join us as we explore how we do this and bring on the innovators who are giving it their all.

Ban Al-Karaghouli, MD

Ban Al-Karaghouli, MD

Always do your best. My favorite Quote is “Shoot for the Moon. If you miss, you will land among the stars”.

somedocs logo without url

Stay in Touch

Be a part of the healthcare revolution. Don’t miss a thing SoMeDocs Does!

Disclaimer: SoMeDocs assumes no responsibility for the accuracy, claims, or content of the individual experts' profiles, contributions and courses. Details within posts cannot be verified. This site does not represent medical advice and you should always consult with your private physician before taking on anything you read online. See SoMeDocs' Terms of Use for more information.

Play Video
Our Founder Answers Your BURNING Question


“Why should I become a member of SoMeDocs if I already have my own space online?”